A Token Response to a Governance Failure

The Victorian Government sat on its taxpayer-funded $850,000 Koala Report for 15 long months before quietly releasing it alongside a $2.6 million funding announcement. While the government attempts to use this token funding as a public distraction, the report itself confirms what rescuers, carers, and advocates have warned for years: Victoria’s koalas are in critical condition.

We have continually told the government that koalas were in serious trouble, yet carers, the very people rescuing and treating these animals every single day, are consistently ignored.  Instead of addressing this ecological emergency, the government’s response offers mere pocket change to fund more of the same outdated “management” programs that brought our koala populations to the brink in the first place.

Better methodologies, or a population in Freefall?

For six years, the government defended its total inaction by claiming Victoria had a “secure and abundant” baseline population of 460,000 koalas. The newly released report shatters that narrative, revealing that our koala population has plummeted to just 225,000—a devastating decline of more than half.  And yet this government maintains the illusion that koalas are abundant by stating on its website:“In New South Wales, Queensland, and the Australian Capital Territory, Koalas are officially listed as endangered. In contrast, some populations in Victoria and South Australia have reached unsustainable densities, causing overbrowsing of preferred eucalypt trees, which requires ongoing management” This statement continues to push the false narrative that koalas are overabundant in Victoria. The only reason koalas exist in “unsustainable” populations is due to a lack of habitat.

Once koalas were listed in NSW, the government committed $190 million over five years for recovery and habitat restoration. Victoria’s $2.6 million offer is less than 1.5% of that package, and even less than the $3.1 million Victoria spent on its previous strategy, which took an unacceptable 19 years to produce.

If past government estimates were based on such wildly unreliable methodology, why did they not publicise that openly at the time and take a precautionary approach to koala management? In response to every letter of concern we sent about their past population estimates, about the declining numbers, we were told everything was fine because their pseudoscience said so.

Behind Closed Doors: Decades of Data, Neglect, and Covert Culling

Victorian koalas have been extensively managed in parts of the southwest, generally in areas where bluegum plantations sit adjacent.  And when we say “managed” we mean population controlled.   Outside of that area koala populations have been silently slipping away because they have received no funding, no monitoring, and no protection from unchecked habitat destruction and fragmentation. Freedom of Information documents recently reveal that the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action (DEECA) has long held internal data showing koalas in state-run fertility programs were in chronically poor health.

This raises damning questions about governance and neglect. If DEECA had decades of data explicitly showing what poor health these koalas were in, why on earth did they need an $850,000 report to tell them what they already knew? Why didn’t they raise the alarm years ago, before these sterilisation programs effectively became an excuse to cull populations under the cover of animal welfare?

During sterilisation programs run by Parks Victoria and Indigenous corporations in and around Budj Bim National Park, koalas are captured and health assessed without proper pathology testing. Instead, assessors use a checklist based on muscle tone and tooth wear to determine whether an animal lives or dies. In fact, FOI records show field euthanasia rates at Budj Bim and surrounding parks have at times exceeded sterilisation numbers, particularly in recent years.  In this recent report researchers euthanised almost half of the random koalas flagged down across the entire state.

46.8% koalas euthanised, 17% Sterlised
22% euthanised, 24% Sterlised

All due to being in chronically poor health.

Following the 2025 fires at Budj Bim National Park, 1,061 koalas were shot from helicopters by professional shooters.

In a parliamentary meeting, the head of DEECA at the time, John Bradley, justified the shooting as a welfare response stating every koala received an individual health assessment with veterinary advice.

Our recent FOI documents reveal that a veterinarian was only present twice in the helicopter, once to assess the koalas pre shooting and again after the three weeks of shooting was completed. 

The 837 koalas killed aerially by gunfire was done by a professional shooter with no vet present. The remaining 224 koalas were assessed and shot on the ground by forest fire management staff and WESN members.

When professional shooters can make life or death decisions for koalas without a vet present we know these types of actions are merely a cover for stealth culling.  Here is the criteria provided to shooters to make their decisions:

  • Animals with either clearly visible indications of emaciation, or burns to any part of the body – Euthanasia
  • Koalas with scruffy, thin brown fur, matted fur, very dirty grey or patches of missing fur – Euthanasia
  • Fur around the ears – if seen to be singed – Euthanasia
  • Koalas with little or no response to the helicopter – Euthanasia
  • Koalas found on an isolated tree with green canopy (per above) – Euthanasia
  • When two or more koalas share one tree – Euthanasia
  • Koalas found on the ground – Euthanasia

No koala, sick or otherwise had a chance of life under this guidance.

Alarmingly, our FOI documents also reveal how the government arrived at shooting koalas from helicopters.  A Parks Victoria document clearly acknowledges that although publicly unacceptable, culling could be a “potentially effective” strategy to control the population in the park.

It also mentions, after 20 years of sterilization programs, that the government had concerns about sterilisation being “too expensive”.

And, the koala deaths around Budj Bim National Park did not stop when the shooting did. Koalas continued to be “euthanised” under sterilisation programs in indigenous protected areas around Budj Bim one month after the shooting stopped. It’s important for the public to know that culling of koalas is not permitted in Australia. Victoria signed on to the National Koala Conservation and Management Strategy, which rejects culling as a management strategy. But, when literally hundreds of koalas are being euthanised under these programs annually, it becomes clear that these programs are in fact stealth culling programs.

The Report’s Glaring Blindspots: Habitat Loss and Translocation

The single biggest flaw of the Victorian Koala Report is that its researchers completely failed to acknowledge habitat loss and fragmentation as the primary driver of koala health decline and mortality. Instead of recognizing that broken landscapes cause sickness, starvation, and forced inbreeding, the report treats poor body condition and poor genetics as isolated health issues. Even worse, official guidelines allow habitat shortages to be used as a justification for field based euthanasia. If a koala is in fair condition but the surrounding habitat is deemed insufficient to sustain it, the animal can be euthanised—effectively punishing the koala for the government’s failure to protect and restore their habitats.

Because the report refused to call out habitat destruction, it also failed to recommend broadscale habitat restoration. The government gave a paltry $600,000 solely for Manna Gums at Wilsons Promontory while ignoring the rest of the state’s degraded landscape.

Equally damning is that the report does not recommend, or even mention, translocation.  Translocation is a vital, proven tool for saving the koalas we have left, yet DEECA routinely dismisses it, claiming it is not an effective management strategy. How they can claim this when our entire mainland population was founded on translocations from French Island is remarkable. Our FOI documents reveal that past post-translocation mortality was actually caused by DEECA’s own appalling operational methods—capturing koalas, subjecting them to invasive surgical sterilisation, and releasing them immediately without pain relief or time to recover.  Bad practice by a government department does not make a proven conservation strategy invalid. Historically, translocation saved mainland koalas from near extinction in the 1940s after populations were rebuilt on French Island.  

DEECA refusing translocation as a strategy is a deliberate choice to avoid shifting away from lethal management practices that are potentially more efficient.  However, when koalas are now in such low numbers and at risk of further decline, lethal management practices can no longer be justified.  

The Bluegum Crisis: 51,000 Koalas Left Unprotected

The report also highlighted that now a quarter of our remaining koala population now depend on commercial blue gum plantations for survival.   Current legislation doesn’t require these companies to leave any trees permanently for these koalas. SO, what will happen to them? 

The Koala Report recommends more research to find out what happens to koalas when plantations are harvested. We don’t need more research into this. Carers have been telling the government what happens to koalas post harvest for decades and they’ve been ignored.

The koalas in blue gum crisis is the consequence of decades of industrial activity operating at the expense of koalas, enabled by a government that has failed in its duty to protect them. The endless pain and suffering inflicted on koalas from this industry is unimaginable and largely unseen due to them being grown on private land.  These companies are largely foreign owned, sending profits offshore.

We know from our own experience and from our FOI documents that every harvest subjects koalas to severe trauma, injury, displacement, and starvation once their habitat is taken.

Yet the government’s $2.6 million plan contains no transition funding, no mention of how these plantation koalas will be protected? Leaving a quarter of our state’s koalas on the chopping block without a plan is an unacceptable failure of policy.

  A Paradigm Shift: From “Management” to Conservation

We must stop the misleading paradigm of koala “management”. “Management” comes from an outdated mentality that treats koalas as an overpopulated nuisance needing control. Koalas do not need to be “managed” through lethal health checks and shooting; they need to be supported through true, non-lethal Conservation strategies.  Saving our remaining wild koalas requires an immediate shift to proactive conservation, such as protection and regeneration of koala habitats and translocations of koalas from plantations and overcrowded areas in the southwest to areas with small populations.  This will not only help to rebuild genetic diversity in our populations, it will reverse the catastrophic trajectory koalas are currently on.

The Koala Alliance is now moving to nominate the Victorian Koala for a formal endangered listing and we’ve called on all political parties to commit to the following koala pledge. 

  • Lead or support the formal assessment and listing of the Victorian Koala under the states threatened species framework;
  • Establish an urgent, properly funded Victorian koala conservation and recovery program that involves large-scale vegetation mapping, and revegetation projects to reconnect habitats;
  • Urgently address the amount of habitat left for koalas following bluegum harvesting, and strengthen controls on harvesting operations;
  • Push for government to address the underlying causes of koala health decline and strengthen genetic resilience; and
  • Shift Victoria’s approach from population management  to genuine conservation and recovery, prioritising well funded translocation programs as a conservation strategy.

We no longer live in a time where people can claim ignorance for what’s happening to koalas. Beyond what lies in the koala report, we know what the root causes are for koala decline and chronically poor health.  The government knows it too. Promising more research to investigate why koalas are in chronically poor health is only to buy the government more time – time that koalas don’t have.